| Horseless Headless Horsemann's Head | 1 |
| MONOCULUS! | 1 |
| Pyrovision Goggles | 1 |
| Power Up Canteen | 1 |
| Ghostly Gibus | 1 |
| Freedom Staff | 1 |
| Haunted Metal Scrap | 1 |
| Buff Banner | 1 |
| Scottish Resistance | 1 |
| Wrangler | 1 |
| Direct Hit | 1 |
| Kritzkrieg | 2 |
| Spellbook Magazine | 1 |
| Mann Co. Cap | 1 |
| World Traveler's Hat | 1 |
| Seal Mask | 1 |
| Idiot Box | 1 |
| Raven's Visage | 1 |
| Grub Grenades | 1 |
| Burny's Boney Bonnet | 1 |
| Scorched Skirt | 1 |
| Tuque or Treat | 1 |
| Unfilled Fancy Spellbook | 1 |
| Sandvich | 2 |
| Rocket Jumper | 1 |
| Steel-Toed Stompers | 1 |
| Mann Co. Supply Crate | 35 |
| Frying Pan | 1 |
| Proof of Purchase | 1 |
| Summer Appetizer Crate | 1 |
| Mildly Disturbing Halloween Mask | 1 |
| Mann Co. Supply Munition | 8 |
| Skull Island Topper | 1 |
| Brown Summer 2013 Cooler | 1 |
| Orange Summer 2013 Cooler | 2 |
| Naughty Winter Crate 2014 | 10 |
| Nice Winter Crate 2014 | 6 |
| Ambassador | 1 |
| End of the Line Community Crate | 2 |
| Battalion's Backup | 1 |
| Reinforced Robot Bomb Stabilizer | 1 |
| Operation Steel Trap Badge | 1 |
| Reclaimed Metal | 1 |
| Samson Skewer | 1 |
| Dapper Disguise | 1 |
| Sun-on-a-Stick | 1 |
| Huo-Long Heater | 1 |
| Concheror | 1 |
| King of Scotland Cape | 1 |
| Samur-Eye | 1 |
| Trencher's Topper | 1 |
| Killer's Kit | 1 |
| Hero's Tail | 1 |
| Tartan Spartan | 1 |
| Pirate Bandana | 2 |
| Panic Attack | 2 |
| Dalokohs Bar | 1 |
| Brainiac Goggles | 1 |
| Sydney Sleeper | 1 |
| Fan O'War | 1 |
| Giftapult | 1 |
| Name Tag | 1 |
| Description Tag | 1 |
| Color No. 216-190-216 | 1 |
| Bootlegger | 1 |
| Crusader's Crossbow | 1 |
| Frontier Justice | 1 |
| Soda Popper | 1 |
| Force-a-Nature | 2 |
| Mantreads | 1 |
| Necronomicrown | 1 |
| Bloodhound | 1 |
| Long Fall Loafers | 1 |
| Unleash the Beast Cosmetic Case | 2 |
| Widowmaker | 1 |
| Cow Mangler 5000 | 1 |
| Killing Gloves of Boxing | 1 |
| Soul Gargoyle | 1 |
| Violet Vermin Case | 2 |
| Darwin's Danger Shield | 1 |
| Back Scratcher | 1 |
| Scream Fortress X War Paint Case | 1 |
| Enforcer | 1 |
| Winter 2019 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Winter 2019 War Paint Case | 1 |
| Wicked Windfall Case | 1 |
| Scream Fortress XII War Paint Case | 1 |
| Family Business | 1 |
| Winter 2021 Cosmetic Case | 5 |
| Doublecross-Comm | 1 |
| Dragon's Fury | 1 |
| Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol | 1 |
| Mad Milk | 1 |
| Bronze Dueling Badge | 1 |
| Disciplinary Action | 1 |
| Summer 2022 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Winter 2022 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Winter 2023 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Summer 2024 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Terrifying Trove Case | 1 |
| Scream Fortress XVI War Paint Case | 1 |
| Dead Ringer | 1 |
| Winter 2024 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Detonator | 1 |
| Reissued Enthusiast's Timepiece | 1 |
| Reissued Dealer's Visor | 1 |
| Winter 2025 Cosmetic Case | 1 |