| Antique Halloween Goodie Cauldron | 1 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking | 4 |
| Professor Speks | 1 |
| Noise Maker - TF Birthday | 1 |
| Party Hat | 1 |
| Halloween Gift Cauldron | 1 |
| Soul Gargoyle | 1 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2017 | 1 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2018 | 1 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2019 | 1 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2020 | 1 |
| Corpse Carrier | 1 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2021 | 1 |
| Noise Maker - Winter Holiday | 1 |
| Anger | 1 |
| Equalizer | 1 |
| Persian Persuader | 1 |
| Dead Ringer | 1 |
| Frying Pan | 1 |
| Beggar's Bazooka | 1 |
| Your Eternal Reward | 2 |
| Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol | 1 |
| Claidheamh Mòr | 1 |
| Secret Saxton | 4 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2022 | 1 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2023 | 1 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2024 | 1 |
| Spectral Stash Case | 7 |
| Ze Übermensch | 1 |
| Greased Lightning | 1 |
| Blighted Beak | 1 |
| Pilotka | 1 |
| Physician's Procedure Mask | 2 |
| Condor Cap | 1 |
| Runner's Warm-Up | 1 |
| A Brush with Death | 1 |
| Medical Mystery | 1 |
| Madame Dixie | 3 |
| Merc Medal | 2 |
| Baronial Badge | 3 |
| Noble Nickel Amassment of Hats | 3 |
| Towering Titanium Pillar of Hats | 3 |
| Bolted Bushman | 3 |
| Western Wear | 3 |
| Magistrate's Mullet | 2 |
| Prairie Heel Biters | 2 |
| Pugilist's Protector | 2 |
| Magnificent Mongolian | 2 |
| Janissary Ketche | 2 |
| Doctor's Sack | 3 |
| Rump-o'-Lantern | 3 |
| Bullet Buzz | 2 |
| Croft's Crest | 2 |
| Prinny Pouch | 3 |
| Faerie Solitaire Pin | 2 |
| Mister Bubbles | 2 |
| Wingstick | 2 |
| German Gonzila | 1 |
| Cotton Head | 2 |
| Sober Stuntman | 2 |
| Cadaver's Cranium | 3 |
| Handyman's Handle | 2 |
| Bloke's Bucket Hat | 2 |
| Baron von Havenaplane | 3 |
| Furious Fukaamigasa | 3 |
| Copper's Hard Top | 3 |
| Medic Mech-Bag | 3 |
| Toy Soldier | 2 |
| Robot Running Man | 3 |
| Gentleman's Gatsby | 3 |
| Noble Amassment of Hats | 3 |
| Waxy Wayfinder | 2 |
| Flipped Trilby | 3 |
| Gift-Stuffed Stocking 2025 | 1 |
| Employee of the Mmmph | 3 |
| Vigilant Pin | 2 |
| Tsarboosh | 2 |
| Bombing Run | 2 |
| Horrific Headsplitter | 3 |
| Brainiac Goggles | 2 |
| Scrap Pack | 1 |
| Bot Dogger | 1 |
| Carouser's Capotain | 1 |
| Stovepipe Sniper Shako | 1 |
| Little Buddy | 3 |
| Cobber Chameleon | 1 |
| Katyusha | 2 |
| Dread Knot | 3 |
| Professor's Peculiarity | 3 |
| Ol' Geezer | 2 |
| Whale Bone Charm | 1 |
| Coupe D'isaster | 3 |
| Geisha Boy | 2 |
| Prancer's Pride | 1 |
| Modest Pile of Hat | 3 |
| Professional's Panama | 3 |
| Googly Gazer | 3 |
| Bootleg Base Metal Billycock | 1 |
| Dry Gulch Gulp | 3 |
| Builder's Blueprints | 3 |
| Orion's Belt | 1 |
| Aladdin's Private Reserve | 3 |
| Heavy's Hockey Hair | 1 |
| Connoisseur's Cap | 1 |
| Frenchman's Beret | 1 |
| Birdcage | 3 |
| Burning Bongos | 2 |
| Whoopee Cap | 2 |
| Conquistador | 2 |
| Crown of the Old Kingdom | 1 |
| Bone Dome | 2 |
| Whiskered Gentleman | 2 |
| Stately Steel Toe | 1 |
| Infernal Impaler | 2 |
| Sultan's Ceremonial | 2 |
| Stout Shako | 2 |
| Virtual Reality Headset | 2 |
| Voodoo JuJu (Slight Return) | 2 |
| Ze Goggles | 1 |
| Valley Forge | 3 |
| Wet Works | 1 |
| Towering Pillar of Hats | 2 |
| Wraith Wrap | 1 |
| Sign of the Wolf's School | 1 |
| Respectless Rubber Glove | 2 |
| Larrikin Robin | 2 |
| Jumper's Jeepcap | 1 |
| Little Bear | 3 |
| Gilded Guard | 2 |
| Dr. Whoa | 3 |
| Heavy-Weight Champ | 1 |
| Idea Tube | 2 |
| Captain's Cocktails | 2 |
| Tam O' Shanter | 1 |
| Pyrotechnic Tote | 3 |
| Burning Bandana | 2 |
| Backpack Broiler | 2 |
| Hive Minder | 1 |
| Berliner's Bucket Helm | 2 |
| Lieutenant Bites | 1 |
| Li'l Snaggletooth | 1 |
| Crocodile Smile | 1 |
| Valhalla Helm | 1 |
| Fruit Shoot | 1 |
| Surgeon's Side Satchel | 2 |
| Coffin Kit | 1 |
| Lucky Shot | 1 |
| Big Daddy | 2 |
| Juggernaut Jacket | 1 |
| Fur-Lined Fighter | 1 |
| Nabler | 2 |
| Mann Co. Supply Crate Key | 16 |
| Aqua Flops | 1 |
| Combustible Kabuto | 1 |
| Heroic Companion Badge | 1 |
| Hitt Mann Badge | 1 |
| Monstrous Memento | 2 |
| Das Fantzipantzen | 1 |
| Tartan Tyrolean | 2 |
| K-9 Mane | 2 |
| Scout Shako | 1 |
| Escapist | 1 |
| Half-Pipe Hurdler | 2 |
| Liquor Locker | 1 |
| Samur-Eye | 1 |
| Borscht Belt | 1 |
| Polar Pullover | 1 |
| Pampered Pyro | 2 |
| Razor Cut | 1 |
| Beep Boy | 1 |
| Tin-1000 | 2 |
| Pyrobotics Pack | 3 |
| Tin Pot | 1 |
| Medic's Mountain Cap | 2 |
| Helmet without a Home | 2 |
| Tipped Lid | 1 |
| Modest Metal Pile of Scrap | 1 |
| Boxcar Bomber | 1 |
| Hotrod | 1 |
| Bear Necessities | 1 |
| Pocket Pyro | 1 |
| Glengarry Bonnet | 1 |
| Crocleather Slouch | 1 |
| Backstabber's Boomslang | 1 |
| Pirate Bandana | 1 |
| Saxton | 1 |
| Heavy Duty Rag | 1 |
| Teufort Tooth Kicker | 2 |
| Minnesota Slick | 1 |
| Defiant Spartan | 1 |
| Big Chief | 1 |
| Business Casual | 2 |
| Gas Guzzler | 1 |
| Private Eye | 1 |
| Toss-Proof Towel | 1 |
| Winter Woodsman | 2 |
| Marshall's Mutton Chops | 1 |
| Reclaimed Metal | 46 |
| Scrap Metal | 46 |
| Champ Stamp | 1 |
| Bubble Pipe | 1 |
| Refined Metal | 398 |
| Balloonicorn | 1 |
| Camera Beard | 1 |
| Napoleon Complex | 1 |
| Pocket Medic | 1 |
| Planeswalker Helm | 1 |
| Himalayan Hair Shirt | 1 |
| Last Straw | 1 |
| Détective Noir | 1 |
| Flunkyware | 1 |
| Pardner's Pompadour | 1 |
| Executioner | 1 |
| Colonial Clogs | 1 |
| Crosslinker's Coil | 1 |
| Surgeon's Stethoscope | 1 |
| Grenadier Helm | 1 |
| Spectre's Spectacles | 1 |
| Pencil Pusher | 1 |
| Das Gutenkutteharen | 1 |
| Doe-Boy | 1 |
| Stormin' Norman | 1 |
| Cool Cat Cardigan | 1 |
| Ruffled Ruprecht | 1 |
| Killer's Kit | 1 |
| Soldier's Stogie | 1 |
| Manniversary Paper Hat | 1 |
| Bruiser's Bandanna | 1 |
| Ninja Cowl | 1 |
| All-Father | 2 |
| Cute Suit | 1 |
| Blood Banker | 1 |
| Belgian Detective | 1 |
| Sneaky Spats of Sneaking | 1 |
| Whiskey Bib | 1 |
| Industrial Festivizer | 1 |
| Hat of Cards | 1 |