| Sandvich | 2 |
| Sandman | 1 |
| Bonk! Atomic Punch | 1 |
| Dead Ringer | 3 |
| Buff Banner | 2 |
| Chargin' Targe | 1 |
| Horseless Headless Horsemann's Head | 1 |
| Taunt: The Director's Vision | 1 |
| Bombinomicon | 1 |
| Power Up Canteen | 1 |
| Pyrovision Goggles | 1 |
| Necro Smasher | 1 |
| Kritz or Treat Canteen | 1 |
| Forgotten King's Restless Head | 1 |
| Giftapult | 1 |
| Iron Curtain | 1 |
| Lugermorph | 1 |
| License to Maim | 1 |
| Enthusiast's Timepiece | 1 |
| Dangeresque, Too? | 1 |
| Samson Skewer | 1 |
| Dapper Disguise | 1 |
| Necronomicrown | 1 |
| Bloodhound | 1 |
| Long Fall Loafers | 1 |
| Bronze Dueling Badge | 1 |
| Classic | 2 |
| Mann Co. Cap | 1 |
| Operation Oil Spill Badge | 1 |
| Black Rose | 1 |
| Killer's Kit | 1 |
| Eyelander | 1 |
| PASS Time Early Participation Pin | 1 |
| Dueling Mini-Game | 1 |
| Spine-Twisting Skull | 1 |
| Equalizer | 1 |
| Soul Gargoyle | 1 |
| Heavy Mask | 1 |
| Halloweiner | 1 |
| Shadowman's Shade | 1 |
| Spellbinder's Bonnet | 1 |
| Vita-Saw | 1 |
| Sticky Jumper | 1 |
| Crispy Golden Locks | 1 |
| Grand Duchess Tiara | 1 |
| Beep Man | 1 |
| Up Pyroscopes | 1 |
| Candleer | 1 |
| Raven's Visage | 1 |
| Nugget Noggin | 1 |
| Pin Pals | 1 |
| Razorback | 1 |
| Cadaver's Capper | 1 |
| Parasight | 1 |
| Axtinguisher | 2 |
| Gunslinger | 1 |
| Jag | 1 |
| World Traveler's Hat | 1 |
| Dark Falkirk Helm | 1 |
| Noise Maker - Winter Holiday | 1 |
| Kritzkrieg | 1 |
| Third Degree | 1 |
| Holiday Punch | 1 |
| Ghostly Gibus | 1 |
| Rescue Ranger | 1 |
| Sharpened Volcano Fragment | 2 |
| Boston Basher | 2 |
| Fan O'War | 1 |
| Black Box | 1 |
| Professor Speks | 1 |
| Back Scratcher | 1 |
| Gloves of Running Urgently | 1 |
| Cozy Camper | 2 |
| Wrap Assassin | 2 |
| Tribalman's Shiv | 2 |
| Tide Turner | 1 |
| Atomizer | 1 |
| Family Business | 1 |
| Scottish Handshake | 1 |
| Machina | 1 |
| Amputator | 1 |
| Widowmaker | 1 |
| Short Circuit | 1 |
| Overdose | 1 |
| Battalion's Backup | 2 |
| Rainblower | 1 |
| Market Gardener | 1 |
| Fortified Compound | 1 |
| Winter 2018 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Bazaar Bargain | 1 |
| Second Banana | 2 |
| Gas Passer | 1 |
| Frontier Justice | 1 |
| Loose Cannon | 1 |
| Winger | 1 |
| Homewrecker | 1 |
| Candy Cane | 1 |
| Rocket Jumper | 1 |
| Reserve Shooter | 1 |
| Crusader's Crossbow | 1 |
| Summer 2021 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Scream Fortress XIII War Paint Case | 1 |
| Wrangler | 1 |
| Winter 2021 Cosmetic Case | 2 |
| Winter 2022 Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Winter 2023 Cosmetic Case | 5 |
| Enforcer | 1 |
| Spectre's Spectacles | 1 |
| Rogue's Col Roule | 1 |
| Natascha | 1 |
| Force-a-Nature | 1 |
| Killing Gloves of Boxing | 1 |
| Huntsman | 1 |
| Loch-n-Load | 3 |
| Big Earner | 1 |
| Your Eternal Reward | 1 |
| Scotsman's Skullcutter | 1 |
| That '70s Chapeau | 1 |
| Scorch Shot | 1 |
| Thermal Thruster | 1 |
| B.A.S.E. Jumper | 1 |
| Bootlegger | 1 |
| Mantreads | 1 |
| Scottish Resistance | 1 |
| Sun-on-a-Stick | 1 |
| Nessie's Nine Iron | 1 |
| Phlogistinator | 1 |
| Postal Pummeler | 2 |
| Half-Zatoichi | 1 |
| Powerjack | 1 |
| Air Strike | 1 |
| Back Scatter | 1 |
| Eviction Notice | 1 |
| Beggar's Bazooka | 1 |
| Huo-Long Heater | 1 |
| Fists of Steel | 1 |
| Hot Hand | 1 |
| Solemn Vow | 1 |
| Neon Annihilator | 1 |
| Gunboats | 1 |
| Ali Baba's Wee Booties | 2 |
| Holy Mackerel | 1 |
| Concheror | 1 |
| Righteous Bison | 1 |
| Degreaser | 2 |
| Ullapool Caber | 2 |
| Quickiebomb Launcher | 2 |
| Red-Tape Recorder | 1 |
| Detonator | 1 |
| Sydney Sleeper | 1 |
| Darwin's Danger Shield | 1 |
| Claidheamh Mòr | 1 |
| Ze Übermensch | 1 |
| Little Buddy | 1 |
| L'Étranger | 1 |
| Ambassador | 1 |
| Spy-Cicle | 1 |
| Cool Cat Cardigan | 1 |
| Diamondback | 1 |
| Attendant | 1 |
| Familiar Fez | 1 |
| Liberty Launcher | 2 |
| Breakneck Baggies | 1 |
| Pomson 6000 | 1 |
| Übersaw | 1 |
| Doc's Holiday | 1 |
| Villain's Veil | 1 |
| North Polar Fleece | 1 |
| Shortstop | 1 |
| Escape Plan | 1 |
| Master's Yellow Belt | 1 |
| Bushwacka | 2 |
| Persian Persuader | 1 |
| Crit-a-Cola | 1 |
| Combat Slacks | 1 |
| AWPer Hand | 1 |
| Maul | 1 |
| Eureka Effect | 1 |
| Vaccinator | 3 |
| Fancy Spellbook | 1 |
| Blutsauger | 1 |
| Mad Milk | 1 |
| Cloak and Dagger | 1 |
| Flare Gun | 1 |
| Dragon's Fury | 2 |
| Refined Metal | 39 |
| Scrap Metal | 7 |
| Reclaimed Metal | 2 |
| Winter 2024 Cosmetic Case | 10 |
| Backburner | 1 |
| Southern Hospitality | 2 |
| Brass Beast | 1 |
| Pretty Boy's Pocket Pistol | 1 |
| Soda Popper | 1 |
| Manmelter | 1 |
| Panic Attack | 1 |
| Original | 2 |
| Baby Face's Blaster | 1 |
| Dalokohs Bar | 2 |
| Buffalo Steak Sandvich | 1 |
| Warrior's Spirit | 1 |
| Splendid Screen | 1 |
| Pain Train | 1 |
| Direct Hit | 1 |
| Blue Moon Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Rainy Day Cosmetic Case | 1 |
| Jarate | 1 |
| Cleaner's Carbine | 2 |
| Cow Mangler 5000 | 1 |
| Hat of Cards | 1 |
| Flying Guillotine | 1 |
| Hitman's Heatmaker | 1 |
| Quick-Fix | 1 |
| Conniver's Kunai | 1 |
| Iron Bomber | 1 |
| Disciplinary Action | 1 |
| Summer 2025 Cosmetic Case | 5 |
| Spectral Stash Case | 2 |